Looking for authentic NY-style pizza in New York Mills? Joe's Pizza prepares honest, scratch-made pies, crispy wings, and loaded subs — delivered right to your doorstep from our Whitesboro ovens.
Now Delivering
To New York Mills
Located just minutes up the road in neighboring Whitesboro, Joe's Pizza has been feeding New York Mills families, students, and businesses since 1964.
From our signature dough tossed daily to premium whole-milk mozzarella and family marinara, nothing is ever pre-made or frozen.
Our proximity to New York Mills ensures your order arrives piping hot and crispy right when you need it for lunch or dinner.
Best known for our upside-down pizza, we combine old-school culinary tradition with fast, friendly neighborhood service.
Closed Mondays. Delivering to New York Mills and the surrounding Mohawk Valley the rest of the week!
We're right around the corner from New York Mills on Main Street in Whitesboro. Call ahead for quick pickup or order online for hot, fresh delivery.
Store Location
117 Main St #1205, Whitesboro, NY 13492
Phone & Orders
(315) 736-1510
Order Online
joespizzaofwhitesboro.comClosed Mondays. Open Tuesday through Sunday — delivering to New York Mills with most orders ready in 15–30 minutes!
👋 Hey New York Mills! I'm Slice — ask me about the menu, delivery, or today's specials!
Krowd